EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF ACCOUNTING, FINANCE & BUSINESS

Motto: Show the world how you think!

Current Issue

The current issue of the journal read...

Authors' guidelines

All you need to know in order to publish in our journal read...

Submission

Here you can submit your paper continue...

Contact

Contact us here...

 

ISSN: 2344 - 102X

ISSN-L: 2344 - 102X



 

Article from Volume 1, Number 1, Year 2013

THE VALUE RELEVANCE OF EARNING MANAGEMENT IN MANUFACTURING INDUSTRIES BEFORE AND DURING THE FINANCIAL CRISIS
Download
Author(s): Stefano Azzali, Luca Fornaciari, Tatiana Mazza
DOI: 10.4316/EJAFB.2013.111
Abstract: This paper empirically investigates the value relevance of reported earnings during the period 2006-2011 for 193 firms (excluding banks and insurance companies) listed in the Milan Stock Exchange, representing about 91.28% of the stock exchange capitalisation (30 April 2012). The objective of the paper is to analyze: a) the value relevance of earnings, cash flow from operations, discretionary and non-discretionary accruals; b) the effect of Global Financial Crisis on the value relevance of accounting information. The paper contributes to examine different components of earnings and to filling a gap extending the analysis to the financial crisis. To test our hypotheses first, we determined the accruals by applying specific models proposed in the international literature, such as the Jones (1991) model and its subsequent amendments; second, we analysed the value relevance of earnings, cash flow and accruals basing the analysis on Ohlson (1995) model, extensively used in previous value relevance researches. The findings show that cash flow from operations, discretionary and non-discretionary accruals have different value relevance. In addition, the results describe the reduction of value relevance during the economic and financial crisis.
Keywords: Earnings Management, Value Relevance, Discretionary And Non-discretionary Accruals, Cash Flow From Operating, Global Financial Crisis
References:
1. Ali A.-Hwang L.S. (2000), Country-specific Factors Related To Financial Reporting And The Value Relevance Of Accounting Data, In Journal Of Accounting Research, Vol. 38, N. 1.
2. Akbar S.- Ali Shah S.Z.-Stark A.W. (2011), The Value Relevance Of Cash Flows, Current Accruals, And Non-current Accruals In The UK, In International Review Of Financial Analysis, Vol. 20, N. 5.
3. Ayers B.C. (1998), Deferred Tax Accounting Under SFAS No. 109: An Empirical Investigation Of Its Incremental Value Relevance Relative To APB No. 11, In Accounting Review, Vol. 73, Pp. 195-212.
4. Azzali S. (2012), Qualitative Characteristics Of Financial Reporting And Accounting Studies For Capital Market, In Financial Reporting, N. 4.
5. Balsam S.-Bartov E.-Marquardt C. (2002), Accruals Management, Investor Sophistication And Equity Valuation: Evidence From 10-Q Filing, In Journal Of Accounting Research, Vol. 40.
6. Barth M.E.-Beaver W.H.-Landsman W.R. (2001), The Relevance Of The Value Relevance Literature For Financial Accounting Standard Setting: Another View, In Journal Of Accounting And Economics, Vol. 31.
7. Barth M.E.-Landsman W.R.-Lang M.H. (2008), International Accounting Standards And Accounting Quality, In Journal Of Accounting Research, Vol. 46, N. 3, June.
8. Barth M.E.-Landsman W.R. (2010), How Did Financial Reporting Contribute To The Financial Crisis?, In European Accounting Review, Vol. 19, N. 3.
9. Barth M.E.-Clinch G. (2009), Scale Effects In Capital Markets-based Accounting Research, In Journal Of Business Finance & Accounting, Vol. 36, N. 3-4.
10. Barth M.E.-Kallapur S. (1996), The Effects Of Cross-sectional Scale Differences On Regression Results In Empirical Accounting Research, In Contemporary Accounting Research, Vol. 13, N. 2.
11. Bartov E.-Goldberg S.R.-Kim M. (2005), Comparative Value Relevance Among German, U.S., And International Accounting Standards: A German Shock Market Perspective, In Journal Of Accounting, Auditing & Finance, Vol. 20, N. 2.
12. Beaver W.H. (2002), Perspectives On Recent Capital Markets Research, In The Accounting Review, Vol. 77, N. 2, April.
13. Beisland L.A. (2009), A Review Of The Value Relevance Literature, In The Open Business Journal, Vol. 2. 14. Biddle G.-Choi J. (2006), Is Comprehensive Income Useful?, In Journal Of Contemporary Accounting And Economics, Vol. 2, N. 1.
15. Brown S.-Kin L.-Lys T. (1999), Use Of R2 In Accounting Research: Measuring Changes In Value Relevance Over The Last Four Decades, In Journal Of Accounting & Economics, Vol. 2, N. 28.
16. Cahan S.F.-Courtenay S.M.-Gronewoller P.L.-Upton D.R. (2000), Value Relevance Of Mandated Comprehensive Income Disclosures, In Journal Of Business Finance & Accounting, Vol. 27, N. 9/10.
17. Callen J.L.-Segal D. (2004), Do Accruals Drive Firm-level Stock Returns? A Variance Decomposition Analysis, In Journal Of Accounting Research, Vol. 42, N. 3.
18. Chalmers K.-Clinch G.-Godfrey J.M. (2011), Changes In Value Relevance Of Accounting Information Upon IFRS Adoption: Evidence From Australia, In Australian Journal Of Management, Vol. 36, N. 2.
19. Choi J.H.-Kim J.B.-Lee J.J. (2010), Value Relevance Of Discretionary Accruals In The Asian Financial Crisis Of 1997-1998, In Journal Of Accounting And Public Policy.
20. Christensen H.B.-Lee E.-Walker M. (2008), Incentives Or Standards: What Determines Accounting Quality Changes Around IFRS Adoption?, Working Paper Manchester Business School, UK, Available At Http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1013054.
21. Cormier D.-Magnan M.-Morard B., The Contractual And Value Relevance Of Reported Earnings In A Dividend-focused Environment, In European Accounting Review, Vol. 9, N. 3, 2000.
22. Cotter J. (1996), Accrual And Cash Flow Accounting Models: A Comparison Of The Value Relevance And Timeliness Of Their Components, In Accounting And Finance, Vol. 36.
23. Courteau L. (2008), Valore D'impresa E Valori Di Bilancio. Modelli Di Valutazione Per Gli Investitori Azionari, Franco Angeli, Milano.
24. Datsgir M.-Velashani A.L. (2008), Comprehensive Income And Net Income As Measures Of Firm Performance: Same Evidence For Scale Effect, In European Journal Of Economics, Finance And Administrative Sciences, Vol. 12.
25. DeAngelo L.E. (1986), Accounting Numbers As Market Valuation Substitutes: A Study Of Management Buyouts Of Public Stockholders, In The Accounting Review, Vol. 61.
26. Dechow P.M.-Dichev I.D. (2002), The Quality Of Accruals And Earnings, In The Accounting Review, Vol. 77.
27. Dechow P.M.-Sloan R.-Sweeney A. (1995), Detecting Earnings Management, In The Accounting Review, Vol. 70.
28. Devalle A. (2010), Misurazione Della Performance Nel Bilancio IFRS. Comprehensive Income, Dibattito Internazionale E Value Relevance, Pearson Prentice Hall, Milano.
29. Devalle A. (2012), Value Relevance Of Accounting Data And Financial Crisis In Europe: An Empirical Analysis, In International Journal Of Accounting And Financial Reporting, Vol. 2, N. 2.
30. Dhaliwal D.-Subramanyam K.R.-Trezevant R., Is Comprehensive Income Superior To Net Income As A Measure Of Firm Performance?, In Journal Of Accounting And Economics, Vol. 26, 1999.
31. Easton P.D.-Sommers G.A. (2003), Scale And The Scale Effect In Market-based Accounting Research, In Journal Of Business Finance & Accounting, Vol. 31, N. 1-2.
32. Easton P.D.-Harris T.S.-Ohlson J.A. (1992), Accounting Earnings Can Explain Most Of Security Returns: The Case Of Long Return Intervals, In Journal Of Accounting And Economics.
33. Entwistle G.M.-Feltham G.D.-Mbagwu C. (2010), The Value Relevance Of Alternative Earnings Measures: A Comparison Of Pro-forma, GAAP And I/B/E/S Earnings, In Journal Of Accounting, Auditing & Finance, Vol. 25, N. 2. 34. Goncharov I.-Hodgson A. (2011), Measuring And Reporting Income In Europe, In Journal Of International Accounting Research, Vol. 10, N. 1.
35. Harris M.-Muller III K. (1999), The Market Valuation Of IAS Versus US Gaap Accounting Measures Using Form 20-F Reconciliations, In Journal Of Accounting And Economics, Vol. 26.
36. Healy P.M. (1985), The Effect Of Bonus Schemes On Accounting Decisions, In Journal Of Accounting & Economics, Vol.7, N. 1/2/3.
37. Holthausen R.W.-Watts R.L. (2001), The Relevance Of The Value-Relevance Literature For Financial Accounting Standard Setting, In Journal Of Accounting And Economics, Vol. 31.
38. Horton J.-Serafeim I. (2007), Does Mandatory IFRS Adoption Improve The Information Environment?, Working Paper, London School Of Economics And Harvard Business School, Available At Http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/ Papers.cfm?abstract_id=1264101.
39. Jermakowicz E. K.-Prather-Kinsey J.-Wulf, I. (2007), The Value Relevance Of Accounting Income Reported By DAX-30 German Companies, In Journal Of International Financial Management & Accounting, Vol. 18, N. 3.
40. Jones J.J. (1991), Earnings Management During Import Relief Investigations, In Journal Of Accounting Research, Vol. 29.
41. Kanagaretnam K.-Mathieu R.-Shehata M. (2009), Usefulness Of Comprehensive Income Reporting In Canada, In Journal Of Accounting And Public Policy, Vol. 28.
42. Kothari S.P.-Zimmerman J., Price And Return Models, In Journal Of Accounting And Economics, Vol. 20, N. 2, 1995.
43. Kothari S.P. (2001), Capital Markets Research In Accounting, In Journal Of Accounting And Economics, Vol. 31. 44. Kothari S.P.-Leone A.-Wasley C. (2005), Performance Matched Discretionary Accrual Measures, In Journal Of Accounting And Economics Vol. 3.
45. Lapointe-Antunes P.-Cormier D.-Magnan M.-Gay-Angers S. (2006), On The Relationship Between Voluntary Disclosure, Earnings Smoothing And The Value-relevance Of Earnings: The Case Of Switzerland, In European Accounting Review, Vol. 15, N. 4.
46. Lim E.-Lu W. (2011), Value Relevance Of Earnings Components During The Global Financial Crisis: Evidence From Australia, Working Paper Presented At The 2011 AFAANZ Conference, Http://www.afaanz.org.
47. Lin S.-Ramond O.-Casta J. (2007), Value Relevance Of Comprehensive Income And Its Components: Evidence From Major European Capital Markets, American Accounting Association (AAA), International Accounting Section (IAS) Mid-Year Conference, 2-3 February 2007.
48. Marquardt C.A.-Wiedman C.I. (2004), The Effect Of Earnings Management On The Value Relevance Of Accounting Information, In Journal Of Business Finance & Accounting, Vol. 31, N. 3 And 4.
49. McNichols M.-Wilson P. (1988), Evidence Of Earnings Management From The Provision For Bad Debts, In Journal Of Accounting Research, Vol. 26, N. 3.
50. Mitra S.-Hossain M. (2009), Value Relevance Of Pension Transition Adjustments And Other Comprehensive Income Components In The Adoption Year Of SFAS No. 158, In Review Of Quantitative Finance And Accounting, Vol. 33.
51. Niskanen J.-Kinnunen J.-Kasanen E. (2000), The Value Relevance Of IAS Reconciliation Components: Empirical Evidence From Finland, In Journal Of Accounting And Public Policy, Vol. 19.
52. Ohlson J.A. (1995), Earnings, Book Values And Dividends In Security Valuation, In Contemporary Accounting Research, Vol. 11, N. 2.
53. Ozkan S.-Kaytmaz Balsari C. (2010), Impact Of Financial Crises On The Value Relevance Of Earnings And Book Value: 1994 And 2001 Crises In Turkey, In Iktisat Isletme Ve Finans, Vol. 25.
54. Paananen M.-Lin H. (2008), The Development Of Accounting Quality Of IAS And IFRS Over Time: The Case Of Germany, Working Paper, University Of Hertfordshire, UK, Available At Http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1066604.
55. So S.-Smith M. (2009), Value-relevance Of Presenting Changes In Fair Value Of Investment Properties In The Income Statement: Evidence From Hong Kong, In Accounting And Business Research, Vol. 39, N. 2.
56. Soderstrom N.S.-Sun K.J. (2007), IFRS Adoption And Accounting Quality:a Review, In European Accountin Review, Vol. 16, N. 4.
57. Subramanyam K.R.-Venkatachalam M. (2007), Earnings, Cash Flows And Ex Post Intrinsic Value Of Equity, In The Accounting Review, Vol. 82, N. 2.
58. Verbeek M. (2006), Econometria, Zanichelli, Bologna.
59. Whelan C.-McNamara R. (2004), The Impact Of Earnings Management On The Value Relevance Of Financial Statement Information, In Social Science Research Network - SSRN, Http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=585704
 
Back to journal ...

 
     
     
Copyright LP/DET 2022